Make a research in all Awards summaries
The Secretariat of the Chamber publishes a summary of the definitive awards rendered during the previous months (since end of 2003).
These summaries can be obtained by annual subscription, by clicking here below, and sent either by ordinary mail, or by e-mail. The cost of this annual subscription amounts to 46 Euros, tax excluded.
In case of particular interest, a specific award can be obtained in its entirety (without the name of the ship and the parties) upon payment of 23 Euros , tax excluded
Subscribe or send a request for (a) particular award(s) with the Number and Date of the award (s) by clicking here.
| N° of awards summary | Release | Keywords | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Awards summary N°1257 | 04-2021 | Port handling contract - Knock by the terminal's handling gantry as it was moving from one bay to the next of the ship's monorail - Responsibilities shared out among the shipowner and the handler. | |
| Awards summary N°1256 | 03-2021 | Synacomex 90 - Wheat in bulk - Missing goods - The charterer's right to bring action for breach of contract against the ship owner on the grounds of a voyage charter - Area of uncertainty regarding the draft surveys and apportionment between the parties - Loss in transit. | |
| Awards summary N°1255 | 04-2021 | 2nd degree - Gencon - Cargo damaged in transit - Materiality of the damage - Volume and quality of the pollutant - Liability - Commercial seaworthiness - Absolute obligation - Inspection of cargo holds at fault - Notice of Readiness (NOR) not exclusionary - Quantum of the damage - Recoverable amounts alone as the basis for compensation. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1254 | 01-2021 | International articles of agreement on a yacht - Non- payment of wages - Expeditious procedure (yes) - Competence of the CAMP (yes) - Unilateral breach of the employment contract (yes) - Reimbursement of costs and payment of wages. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1253 | 12-2020 | 2nd degree - Voyage charter party - Synacomex charter party- Ports of unloading not mentioned in the charter party - Charterer's guarantee on a draught of water limit at the port(s) of unloading - (non) safe port. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1252 | 12-2020 | Chartering - Charterer - Vessel delayed on departure due to the belated issuance of phytosanitary certificates - Effects - Charterer's liability - The charterer's creditor company - Seizure of the vessel - Unjustified seizure - Shared liability. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1251 | 08-2020 | Ship building - Offshore cruising - Accident at sea after three and a half years' navigation - loss at sea of the rudder blade and part of the steering gear - Yachtbuilder's liability for hidden defect - Evidence not provided. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1250 | 04-2020 | Second degree - Bare boat charter with put option – Price clause – Interpretation or misinterpretation ? – Strict interpretation. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1249 | 03-2020 | C/P Heavyliftvoy - Joinder of actions - Ship chartered by freight forwarder for loading a patrol vessel - Damage to the patrol vessel's hull – Claim for compensation from the carrier by the freight forwarder and its insurer – Claim for payment of shipowner's demurrage to the charterer - Shipowner's liability (yes) – Freight forwarder exempted from paying demurrage. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1247 | 02-2020 | C/P Synacomex 90 – Wheat in bulk - Belated customs clearance of the ship after loading – Demurrage computation – Defendant unrepresented. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1246 | 10-2019 | C/P Synacomex – Negotiation for a second loading berth – Demurrage rate – Admissibility of the claimant's action (yes) – Calculated lay time – Deposit paid into the CAMP bank account by the Charterer. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1245 | 11-2019 | Passenger boat – Breaking of an engine drive shaft five years after delivery by the shipyard – Shared responsibility between the shipyard and the bare-boat charterer. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1244 | 07-2019 | During discharging, shock between a gantry crane and a containership crane - Legal interest – Subrogated insurers – Stevedore’s liability – Ship-board duty of supervision. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1243 | 05-2019 | (second degree) – C/P Synacomex 90 – Disponent owner – Rice cargo – Long waiting on roads at discharging – Two fumigations ordered by the head-owner – Partial payment of fumigation costs by the voyage charterer. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1242 | 12-2018 | Marine cargo insurance policy all risks cover – Theft in a rice cargo during warehousing – Collateral management agreement – Average adjuster – Damage estimate – Unexplained shortage – Lack of evidence – Insured’s fault – Reduction of indemnity. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1241 | 10-2018 | Steel products under B/L. Protracted waiting time on roads at discharging without remittance of NOR – Cargo damages – Letter of undertaking by shipowner’s P&I Club giving competence to CAMP - Hague-Visby rules – Receivers right to act – Carrier partial liability | Read |
| Awards summary N°1240 | 09-2018 | C/P Synacomex – Cargo of wheat – FIO freight – Clauses 5 et 23 – Handling risks – Brussels Convention. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1239 | 02-2018 | C/P Synacomex - Wheat flour in bags – Wet damage – Letter of undertaking by P&I Club to receivers – Claim for restitution – Owner’s liability (yes) – Demurrage account adjustment | Read |
| Awards summary N°1238 | 12-2017 | C/P Gencon – Applicable law – Carriage of lychees to be refrigerated – Cargo damage – Subrogated insurers – Vessel’s liability (yes) – Damage assessment | Read |
| Awards summary N°1237 | 10-2017 | C/P Synacomex 90 – Wheat flour in bags – Dispute about handling expenses into a tween decker – Claimant withdrawal – Defendant counter-claim partially granted. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1236 | 12-2017 | C/P Heavyliftvoy – Transportation and laying down of marine turbine at sea and connection to cable of terrestrial grid – Departure from the spot before work completion – Chartering contract or business contract – Freight deemed earned and non- returnable (yes) – Counter-claim time-barred (no) – Shipowner gross negligence (no). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1235 | 9-2017 | Rice in bags under B/L – Shortage and wet damage to cargo – Letter of undertaking by P&I Club – Insurer subrogated in the rights of the importer – Qualification as sea carrier and responsibility of the shipowner (yes). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1234 | 9-2017 | (second degree) - C/P Mediterranean Iron Ore – Grounding outside the fairway – Navigational fault – Hague-Visby rules applicable – Shipowner not responsible – Restitution of Insurers contribution to General Average (no). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1233 | 7-2017 | 2nd degree - Salvage agreement between a pilot station and a pleasure yacht – Agreement validity (yes) – Ship in danger (yes) – Settlement of a reward. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1232 | 5-2017 | C/P Synacomex – Voyage postponed – Conclusion of a second C/P – Unjustified charterer failure to perform – Article 13 of decree of 31 December 1966 – Compensation for the loss (yes). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1231 | 2-2017 | Rice in bags - French marine cargo insurance policy – Ship damage during voyage – Cargo discharging and redirection – Goods depreciation due to late arrival near the use-by-date - Indemnification by insurer (no). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1230 | 6-2016 | Shipbuilding contract – Sale of a large pleasure boat – Work uncompleted – Non delivery following seller’s liquidation – Assessment of price as is and balance due. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1229 | 1-2017 | 2nd degree - Liner agency agreement – Arbitration clause – Referral to a civil court – English law – CAMP competence (partial). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1228 | 4-2016 | Time-charter NYPE 1946 – Rice in bags – Damages and shortage on discharging – Inter-Club Agreement – Interest in acting and admissibility (no) – “Nobody may plead by proxy” rule. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1227 | 3-2016 | Seed potatoes under B/L – Ship arrested after loading – Discharging of germinating cargo ordered by loading port authorities – Claim from receiver – Carrier’s liability (yes). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1226 | 9-2015 | Shipbuilding contract for a catamaran for service in offshore windfarms – Construction delayed – Instalment not paid – Exi s tence of cont ract (yes ) – Customer’s breach (yes) – Damages (no). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1225 | 9-2015 | 2nd degree – Liner agency agreement - Delivery of container s agains t let ter s of guarantee without production of B/L - Legal framework of Carrier/Agent contractual relationship – Time bar application - Agent’s liability. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1224 | 8-2015 | N/Y Produce 1946 – Rice in bags – Congenbill B/L – Shortage and dama g e s to c a r go – L e t t e r s of undertaking - Subrogated insurers – Admissibility (yes) – Shipowner sea carrier – Shipowner’s liability for shortage (100 %) for losses due to mould (50 %). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1223 | 7-2015 | Rice in bags under B/L – Shortage at discharging – Letter of undertaking giving competence to CAMP - Subrogated insurers – Carrier’s liability (yes). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1222 | 1-2015 | 2nd degree - C/P Synacomex 90 – Addendum to contract – Non reversibility between discharging ports – Laytime as a reward for freight (yes). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1221 | 8-2014 | T/C NYPE 1946 – English law – Claimant shipowner – Off-hire for cranes breakdowns – Crane damaged by stevedores – Claim for shortage – Inter Club Agreement application (no). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1220 | 9-2014 | C/P Synacomex 90 – Wheat in bulk – Cargo wetting – Claimant insurers – Admissibility (yes) – Legal subrogation (yes) – FIO clause – Ship owner’s liability (no). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1219 | 7-2014 | C/P Supplytime 2005 – Multi-purpose support vessel – Cablelaying – Draft in excess – Vessel deficiencies – Shipowner’s liability for excessive draft (no), for deficiencies (yes). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1218 | 4-2014 | Rice in bags under B/L – Shortage and torn bags at discharging – CAMP competence – Receivers entitled to sue – Carrier’s liability for shortage (yes), for torn bags (partly). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1217 | 6-2014 | Transport of refrigerated containers – Lack of means of wedging inside containers – Shipper’s fault – Carrier’s liability (no). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1216 | 6-2014 | Hull and machinery insurance of a fishing boat – Indemnification denial – Clause printed in indistinctive types – Insurer condemned – No measures of conservation taken by the insured – Partial indemnification. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1215 | 5-2014 | C/P Synacomex 90 – Social unrests, strike, curfew – Force majeure (no) – Laytime calculation. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1214 | 11-2013 | Cargo insurance – Sugar cargo – Defaulting buyer – Extended storage – “All risks except…” policy – Appraisement of loss suffered by seller. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1213 | 10-2013 | C/P Gencon – Phosphate cargo – Deballasting problem – Notice of readiness – Dead-freight claim – Attachment in New-York based on Rule B – Counterclaim for improper attachment. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1212 | 11-2013 | 2nd degree – C/P Synacomex 90 – Demurrage – Dispute on notice of readiness – Inaccessibility and unavailability of loading berth – Force majeure (yes). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1211 | 8-2013 | Rice in bags under B/L – Damages to cargo – Letter of undertaking – Subrogated underwriters – French Law – General Paramount clause – FIO clause (not applicable) – Carrier’s liability (yes). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1210 | 11-2013 | second degree) – Partnership agreement between an individual producing broker and a marine insurance brokerage company in order to develop a portfolio jointly - Cancellations of policies managed by the broker – Competence of CAMP (yes) - Client misappropriation (yes). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1209 | 9-2013 | C/P Synacomex 90 – Flour in bags – Damage to cargo – Subrogated insurers – Admissibility (yes) – Evidence of vessel’s liability (unproved). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1208 | 6-2013 | C/P Synacomex – Port congested and bad weather – Berthing delayed – Dispute on laytime calculation – Validity of remittance of NOR on roads (yes) – Time counting during delay on roads (yes). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1207 | 7-2013 | Second Degree - C/P Gencon – Carriage of refrigerated lychees - Competence of CAMP – English law – Guarantee of maximum safe speed – Vessel delayed – Disponent owner’s liability (yes) – Falling price of fruit on arrival – Damage calculation. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1206 | 5-2013 | C/P Orevoy – Hatch cover damaged during discharging – Provisional repairs followed two years later by definitive repairs in China. Claim from charterer to the disponent owner to be refunded of part of the cost of provisional repairs and demurrage. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1205 | 5-2013 | C/P Orevoy – Hatch cover damaged during discharging – Provisional repairs followed two years later by definitive repairs in China - Charterer’s liability (yes). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1204 | 5-2013 | Synacomex 90 – Political unrest in Egypt – Berthing delayed – Dispute on laytime calculation at discharging – Validity of notice of readiness tendered on roads (yes) – Application of clause 25 (no). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1203 | 5-2013 | Alleged collision of a long cable towed by a seismic survey vessel with a containership - Referral to CAMP by virtue of a letter of undertaking – Involvement of the container ship (yes ) – Liability (unproved). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1202 | 9-2012 | Partnership agreement between a trader and a carrier – Carriage of citrus fruit and early vegetables – Engine break down – Cargo damage – Legal subrogation (yes) – Carrier’s liability (yes). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1201 | 10-2012 | C/P Gencon – English law – Carriage of lychees to be refrigerated – London Reefer Clause – Cargo damage – Subrogated insurers – Vessel’s liability – Damage assessment. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1200 | 12-2012 | C/P Synacomex 90 – Freight payment in wrong currency – Claim for refund – N.O.R. remittance on roads – Letter of indemnity (L.O.I.) – Overage exemption certificate (O.E.C.) – WIFPON clause – Laytime computation. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1199 | 11-2012 | C/P Synacomex 90 – Cargo of soyabean meals from Argentina discharged in Algeria – Shortage ascertained by port weighingbridge. Ship responsibility (no) | Read |
| Awards summary N°1198 | 8-2012 | C/P Baltimore Form C – Loading of wheat cargo at Baton Rouge – FIO terms – De-ballasting operation abnormally lengthy – Application of the terminal tariff. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1197 | 7-2012 | C/P Synacomex – Unseaworthiness for mismanagement and breach to regulations – Lack of insurance – Poor maintenance – Lack of documentation on board – Arrest and sale of ship. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1196 | 9-2012 | 2nd degree – C/P Gencon – Damage by sea water to a cargo of fertiliser – Subrogated underwriters – Receiver’s obligation to minimize his damage – Ship owner liability (yes). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1195 | 7-2012 | Voyage charter – Discharging in Ivory Coast - European regulation forbidding any financial relationship with Ivory Coast authorities – Impossibility to perform – Ship Owner compensation (yes) – Unrecovered expenses (yes ) – Los to pportunity of profit (no). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1194 | 6-2012 | C/P Synacomex 2000 – English law – Wheat in bulk – Discharging completed six months after arrival in Chittagong – Demurrage calculation in dispute – Charterer’s liability (yes). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1193 | 6-2012 | C/P Synacomex – Wet damage to a cargo of wheat in bulk – Refusal by receivers and port terminal to discharge part of the cargo – Distress sale by ship owner – Dispute on demurrage account. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1192 | 2-2012 | C/P GENCON – DAP cargo damaged by water ingress – Personal want of due diligence (yes) – Shipowner’s liability (yes) – Indemnification for depreciation and consequential expenses. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1191 | 1-2012 | Rice in bags under B/L to order - Surrogate insurer - Loss payee clause - Admissibility (yes) – Assessment of loss. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1190 | 2-2012 | Agency agreement - Refusal by receiver of a rice cargo damaged after a long stay in port – Agent liability (yes) - Claim for demurrage of containers (partly justified) – Counterclaim from agent (inadmissible). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1189 | 1-2012 | Cargo of rice in bags - Surrogate insurer - Admissibility (yes) - Brussels Convention of 1924 – English law - Shortage - Breach by carrier (yes) - Application of FIOS clause - Rebate on amount of damages caused by wetting. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1188 | 12-2011 | Rice in bags under B/L - Shortage and damages to cargo – Letter of undertaking giving jurisdiction to CAMP - Carrier’s liability for shortage (yes), for moisture and torn bags (in part). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1187 | 11-2011 | C h a r t e r - P a r t y SYNACOMEX 90 – Damage caused by stevedores – Claim directly against charterer – Admissibility (no). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1186 | 9-2011 | C h a r t e r - P a r t y SYNACOMEX and shipment under CONGENBILL – Barley in bulk – Cargo short delivered – Wastage of 0.71 %. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1185 | 7-2011 | C h a r t e r - P a r t y SYNACOMEX – Wheat in bulk – Caked cargo found during discharging – Cargo damaged before loading – Charterers liability (yes). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1184 | 7-2011 | C h a r t e r - P a r t y SYNACOMEX 90 – Beginning of laytime – Port closure due to weather conditions – Dispute on laytime calculation. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1183 | 6-2011 | Agency contract – Issuance of a Bill of Lading with declaration of value without prior shipowner agreement – Wrong wording of a Bill of Lading – Arbitrators competence. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1182 | 4-2011 | Sale contract of a fishing vessel - Situation of a sailor attached to the vessel by a contract of employment - Maritime Labor code - Dismissal - contractual obligation of guarantee. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1181 | 4-2011 | Synacomex – Voyage Charter - Damage to cargo – Charterparty Bill of lading with no heading - Disponent owner - Identification of the Carrier. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1180 | 2-2011 | 2nd degree Synacomex – Amended Centrocon Strike Clause (ACSC) – Blockade of roads outside the harbour affecting the loading – Neut ral izat ion of layt ime and exemption of demurrage – Limit: “Once on demurrage, always on demurrage” – Rule B (Yes). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1179 | 12-2010 | Contract of affreightment – Hardship situation (No) – Partial execution of contracts – Force majeure (No). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1178 | 10-2010 | Yacht contract of construction – Guaranteed works entrusted to a third party contractor – Financial dispute between shipyard and repair yard. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1177 | 10-2010 | Yacht contract of construction – Invalid for fraud (No) – Expert appointment (No). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1176 | 6-2010 | Second degree : Contract of Affreightment (COA) - Shipowner’s partial fulfilment - Protective seizure in New-York (Rule B) - Interest of a subsidiary company to take action (Yes) – Estoppel (No) - Damage for substitute chartered vessel (Yes). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1175 | 5-2010 | (Second degree) : Carriage of bagged rice under B/L - Letter of guarantee - Damaged and shortage cargo at discharging - Shipowner liability. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1174 | 3-2010 | Gencon C/P - Reefer carriage - Damages to cargo – Commercial unseaworthiness state – Shipowner liability. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1173 | 2-2010 | Sale contract and arbitration clause - Competence on the merits (no) - Plaintiff withdrawal - Defendant’s accessory costs. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1172 | 2-2010 | Contract of affreightment – Hardship clause – Claim for lack of jurisdiction rejected. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1171 | 1-2010 | Shipbuilding contract for a tuna fishing vessel – Claim for contribution from third party. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1170 | 2-2010 | Ship building contract - Guarantee claim - Judicial survey - Respect of contractual procedures - Workmanship. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1169 | 2-2010 | Second degree – NYPE c/p – Grounding – Nautical fault in navigating the vessel – « Paramount » and « Exceptions » clauses – Claim for costs resulting from the grounding rejected. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1168 | 12-2009 | Damages to bulk cargo – COA and Gencon c/p – Arbitration clause in a chain of contracts. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1167 | 10-2009 | Carriage of bagged rice under bill of lading – Cargo loaded in winter in China bound to West Africa coast – Wet damages – Letter of guarantee giving jurisdiction to the CAMP. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1166 | 10-2009 | Gencon C-P – Period of time excluded from laytime – Ship's agent contract. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1165 | 9-2009 | Supplytime C-P – Fasttrack procedure – Motto : « Criminal proceedings take precedence over civil proceedings » - Stay of proceedings (No). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1164 | 7-2009 | Gencon C-P – Carriage of refrigerated cargo – Speed warranty : maximum safe speed – Vessel arrived at disport behind schedule – No evidence of bad weather – Fruit market price fall at the date of arrival - Monetary loss. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1163 | 9-2009 | Synacomex C-P – Strike clause – Owners refusal to berth – Demurrage (No). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1162 | 8-2009 | (Second degree) – Time C/P - Carriage of bagged rice under b/l - Cargo damage - Letter of guarantee - Ostensible authority – Jurisdiction. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1161 | 5-2009 | Gencon c-p – Cargo to be loaded « always last in/first out » - Deviation – Late delivery of cargo – Penalty. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1160 | 3-2009 | Gencon c-p – Voyage not performed – Chartering of a substitute vessel. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1159 | 11-2008 | Sale contract for yachts - Partial non-performance – Cancellation clause. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1158 | 11-2008 | Synacomex charter-party – Bulk maize – Cargo shortage – Action for indemnity against the charterer to guarantee any court decision against the owner – Owner performing its obligations – Guarantee required from charterers was well founded. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1157 | 11-2008 | Synacomex charter-party and bill of lading – Bulk maize – Cargo shortage – Liability of the owner as sea carrier. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1156 | 8-2008 | Charter-party bill of lading – Bagged rice – Cargo damage and shortage – Paramount clause and applicable law – Liability of the sea-carrier. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1155 | 5-2008 | Second degree - « Sugar » c-p – Refusal of the Master to discharge in spite a letter of indemnity (LOI) was tendered by the charterer – Loss of time – Demurrage due by the charterer. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1154 | 5-2008 | Second degree - "Asbatankvoy" c-p – Damages to the vessel – Late delivery of the cargo – Unseaworthiness – Owner negligence – Commercial prejudice. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1153 | 4-2008 | « Synacomex » c-p – Cargo damages – Charterer obligation to discharge the cargo – Time lost due to a reduced discharging rate deducted from laytime. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1152 | 3-2008 | Second degree – « Baltimore form C » c-p – Contamination of a soya bean meal cargo – English law to apply – Charterer and receiver part of the same group of companies – Which legal system has relevance ? | Read |
| Awards summary N°1151 | 3-2008 | Second degree – Unsigned « Synacomex » c-p – Jurisdiction – Validity of the notice of readiness (NOR) – Refusal to discharge against a letter of indemnity (LOI). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1150 | 1-2008 | Second degree – VSA (vessel sharing agreement) – Group of companies – Title to sue – Nautical fault – Peril of the sea – Container lashing - Liability of the owner (No). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1149 | 11-2007 | Transport of bagged rice under b/l – Letter of indemnity – Damages and shortage – Owner liable as being the carrier. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1148 | 11-2007 | Voyage charter – Identity of one party – Non-performance. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1147 | 11-2007 | Second degree – Maritime agency contract – Cancellation – Compensation (Yes). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1146 | 9-2007 | Synacomex C-P – No discharge in the absence of b/l – Time lost – Demurrage (Yes). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1145 | 9-2007 | Collateral management agreement – Cargo vanishing and cargo damages – Collateral manager liable for the vanishing (Yes) – for the damages (No). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1144 | 8-2007 | Carriage of bagged rice under B/L – Shortage and damages – B/L with no heading – Identity of the sea carrier, timecharterer of the vessel. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1143 | 9-2007 | C-P Synacomex – Balance of freight resulting from unpaid despatch money – Tender of notice of readiness – Working days. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1142 | 9-2007 | Carriage of bagged rice under B/L – Shortage and damage – Substitution of debtor for indemnity of insurance purpose – Subrogated underwriters – Full head owner liability as carrier for wet cargo damages, liability to be shared for damages due to stevedore mishandling. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1141 | 7-2007 | C-P bill of lading – Bagged rice – Shortage and damage – Time-charterer as carrier – Liability in tort of the head owner (No). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1140 | 5-2007 | Gencon c/p - Identity of parties – Chartering broker, party to the contract and acting as charterer (Yes) – Party acting on behalf of the receiver (No) – Demurrage. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1139 | 5-2007 | Gencon c/p – Notice of readiness – NOR regularly tendered (Yes) – Laytime – Time not to count – Holds rightly rejected because of the specific characteristics of the cargo - Demurrage – Time counting. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1138 | 4-2007 | (2nd degree) - Synacomex c/p - Cargo damage – Unseaworthiness (No) – Inherent vice (Yes) – Body of indications hints matching together. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1137 | 3-2007 | Carriage of rice under b/l – Cargo damage – Owner liable as carrier – Inherent vice (No) – Circumstances surrounding the voyage not correctly assessed (Yes) – Lack of appropriate care to the cargo (Yes) – Unseaworthiness (Yes). | Read |
| Awards summary N°1136 | 2-2007 | B/L used with a Gencon c-p – Legal action before a Tribunal lacking jurisdiction interrupts the time bar. Consignee a subsidiary of the charterer – Carrier not liable for damages to steel products cargo. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1135 | 2-2007 | (2nd degree) – Vessel grounded during a river transit - Intervention of a tug – Mere towing service but no assistance. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1134 | 12-2006 | Arbitration wrongly brought against an owner which was not a party to the c-p to which the arbitration clause refers – Lack of jurisdiction of the arbitration Tribunal. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1133 | 1-2007 | B/L showing the loaded weight – Owners’obligation to discharge the B/L weight. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1132 | 10-2006 | (Second degree) : Synacomex c/p – Arbitration clause of the c/p incorporated into the b/l – Validity of unsigned c/p. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1131 | 7-2006 | Damages to the cargo – Contradictory tally reports – Carrier’s responsability. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1130 | 5-2006 | Synacomex c/p – Grounding – Safe port/berth – Obligation to continue the voyage. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1129 | 5-2006 | Damages to steel products – Perils of the sea – Carrier’s responsability. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1126 | 12-2005 | Port services – Damages to a shore gantry crane and a vessel crane. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1125 | 12-2005 | Damage to cargo – Unseaworthiness – Obligation to discharge – Right to not carry out a contractual obligation due to nonperformance of the other party. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1123 | 12-2005 | Charter-party bill of lading marked «FIOS». | Read |
| Awards summary N°1122 | 12-2005 | Agency agreement – Balance of accounts. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1121 | 7-2005 | Sugar c/p – Letter of undertaking – Jurisdiction - Stevedores as owners’ servants. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1120 | 9-2005 | Gencon c/p – Waiting time for the ice-breaker to count as laytime. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1119 | 7-2005 | Amwelsh c/p – Wet damages – Non watertight hatch covers – Bad weather non excepted case. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1118 | 10-2005 | Synacomex c/p – “Clean on board” bill of lading. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1117 | 10-2005 | Agency contract – Cancellation – Indemnity claim. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1116 | 6-2005 | Synacomex c-p - Vessel failing to arrive at loadport – Cargo shortage. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1115 | 6-2005 | Barecon c-p – Unpaid hire. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1114 | 6-2005 | (Second degree) Ship’s cranes at the disposal of the charterer. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1113 | 5-2005 | Time charter – Final account – Assignment – Time bar. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1112 | 5-2005 | Clean on board bills of lading. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1111 | 3-2005 | Syncomex c-p – Safe port/berth. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1110 | 4-2005 | (Second degree) Slot charter – Damage to refrigerated goods stowed in a container. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1109 | 5-2005 | (Second degree) Fire in cargo – Undeclared general average. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1108 | 4-2005 | (Second degree) Collision. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1107 | 3-2005 | (Second degree) Wet damages - Authorities denying permission to discharge. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1106 | 3-2005 | Rejection of cargo found polluted by the Captain. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1105 | 1-2005 | Time-charter - Loss of containers loaded on deck in bad weather. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1104 | 12-2004 | Laytime calculation. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1103 | 11-2004 | (Second degree) Vessel detained by Customs once loaded. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1102 | 8-2004 | (Second degree) Obligation to discharge – Safe port. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1101 | 6-2004 | Collision – Time-bar – Quantum of damages. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1100 | 5-2004 | Slot allocation contract - Time bar – Liability. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1099 | 6-2004 | Multiple parties and contracts - Applicable law - Grounding - Safe port clause - General average. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1098 | 5-2004 | Vessel readiness to load. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1097 | 6-2004 | Demurrage. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1095 | 4-2004 | Second-hand ship sale – Waiver of recourse. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1094 | 4-2004 | Assistance at sea. | Read |
| Awards summary N°1092 | 10-2003 | Cargo damage – Ingress of sea water. | Read |
16, rue Daunou 75002 PARIS